Critiques From Aleksander Rotner

	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/25/2009 7:00:06 PM It's a rare, beautiful photo. Mysterious, magical and engaging
Photo By: Milena G  (K:759)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/25/2009 3:06:35 PM The framing makes it so special. A wonderful composition, great camera placement, dreamy lighting, a shot one in a million
Photo By: mustafa kubilay kuzu  (K:220)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/25/2009 11:19:40 AM An old-fashion postcard made anew. A striking pose, a care-free hairdo, erotic pose, promising lips...Great. Only the vignette on the background distracts.
Photo By: Roman_tyka .  (K:544)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/24/2009 5:38:50 PM Address and rental fee, please. I want to retire there. Beautifully expressed
Photo By: Chaterine Harton  (K:4059)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/23/2009 8:22:05 PM Love the idea of someone just being carefree. The picture looks like a frame from an old B/W movie and I like it very much. The girl, however would, I thing, look more a part of the picture, being less sharp and contrasty.
Photo By: txules  .  (K:49482)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/23/2009 7:34:22 PM Thanks, it's actually my father. A snapshot taken two decades ago found a new life in Photoshop
Photo By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/23/2009 5:45:24 PM This and #5 are my favorite pictures. I like the emotional impact the images have. The loneliness, the stubbornness, the strength! A beautiful contrast between the enveloping softness of the sky and the crisp features of the tree. The lighting couldn't be more perfect. I like to manipulate (create)my pictures, but it does not stop me from admiring a simple beauty, like yours. Aleksander
Photo By: Ania Blazejewska  (K:24026)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/23/2009 5:21:30 PM Thanks, Ania. You are always kind to my work. Dzieki, zawsze bylas mile ustawiona do moich zdjec. Gdzie mieszkasz?
Photo By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/21/2009 3:51:16 PM A sad world of wonder. Wish, it could be fixed. A beautiful image
Photo By: derek pantling  (K:1626)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/20/2009 11:11:20 PM I'm very pleased, that the picture resonated with you. Thanks for kind words
Photo By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/20/2009 9:32:22 PM Molto grazzie, Luciano
Photo By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/19/2009 7:36:06 PM Like an old illustration/advertisement by Norman Rockwell. Beautiful. The barely visible patch of blue sky on the top makes you realize it's a photograph. An important detail well placed.
Photo By: Luciano Caturegli  (K:5920)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/19/2009 7:28:42 PM A real beauty. The transition from the fog into the sharper bckg is the centerpiece, but the crispness of the birds is also adding to the overall effect. Only the yellow cast is I think wrong. Could benefit from more warmth
Photo By: Amer Jassim  (K:498)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/23/2008 4:05:14 PM A simple picture, but those little things you did to it elevated this photograph to a work of beauty
Photo By: jacques brisebois  (K:70392)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/23/2008 4:00:54 PM A rare beauty
Photo By: saleh tafazoli  (K:591)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/17/2008 4:42:37 PM A pure delight. Aż się oczy świecą
Photo By: Tomasz Kukula  (K:-10)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/15/2008 6:16:52 PM Very interesting. I like the concept and the results
Photo By: Luca Peccerillo  (K:15873)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/14/2008 2:17:14 AM I absolutely love it. The expression, the composition, the exposure. It is different, delicate, a pencil sketch, a fashion statement. The eyes treatment is fascinating. The portrait also provides an unexpected glimpse into the model's mind of a thinking person, not just a pretty, mindless face.
Photo By: rebecca claassen  (K:16443)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/13/2008 12:28:22 AM Thanks so much for stopping by. I used a Photoshop plug-in Alien Skin Snap Art
Photo By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/12/2008 2:26:30 PM Cannot comment on the photo, because it no longer exists, but what you created instead is an incredible, imaginative art and wonder, what a daring person can do. My only personal objection is the blue-spread choice of color for the house, it reminds me of a film negative, probably because of the proximity to the black on the left.
Photo By: Salvador María Lozada  (K:19409)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/10/2008 7:56:19 PM Nothing significant to add. It's just one of those pictures,that feed our imagination, and makes us glad to witness the mystery of light, shadows and warm colors
Photo By: Neil White  (K:9159)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/10/2008 2:33:44 PM Like fire and ice. Two colliding worlds. Makes strong impression.
Photo By: Debjit Ghosh  (K:3425)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/10/2008 2:28:47 PM A beautiful moment captured in time. A timeless tribute to what is important in life. Lighting, softness and focus first class
Photo By: saad alqasem  (K:1202)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/10/2008 4:28:40 AM Beautiful composition, with a focus from here to eternity
Photo By: Eb Mueller  (K:23797)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/10/2008 4:26:00 AM Gust. Glad, that you, who are a true artist liked my impression of an Old Town in Warsaw
Photo By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/10/2008 4:20:57 AM Thank you for the appreciation AR
Photo By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/10/2008 2:56:19 AM Bold idea, but emotionally detached and visually disconnected. The void is too strong. Just the face part would be expressive enough.
Photo By: Farrokh Vahabzadeh  (K:274)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   2/4/2008 7:18:16 PM Unique and beautiful
Photo By: Luis  Steinberg   (K:19636)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   11/8/2004 12:14:07 PM It looks like a true firebird...I like the magic of this.
Photo By: Dee N  (K:272)
	Critique By: Aleksander Rotner  (K:169)   11/6/2004 8:54:48 PM It is an ugly, dirty, depressing corner in a forgotten world, but I would give anything to step into it and take that picture!
Photo By: martino balestreri  (K:817)