|
|
fotogr@vi
{K:50665} 7/17/2008
|
Sorry, had to re-load. Here are the comments it had received:
Stan Ciszek {K:25128} 7/17/2008
Outstanding shot Avi,
Very creative,nice composition,lighting and interesting idea.
Stan.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rate comment (Good | Avg | Poor | Abuse)
Reply to Ivonne *
Ivonne * {K:8234} 7/17/2008
Avi,
very interesting look, great shot...Excellent b&w tones..
I like it !
Warm hugs,
Ivi
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rate comment (Good | Avg | Poor | Abuse)
Reply to Syamantak Das
Syamantak Das {K:2340} 7/17/2008
ekta kothaa bolo...mohilar ki khub proyojon chhilo?..I'm just trying to understand..
|
|
|
|
|
Syamantak Das
{K:2458} 7/17/2008
|
aaaaahhh....eibar hoyechey!! :)
|
|
|
|
|
Fadel J
{K:13584} 7/17/2008
|
Yes! you know I just saw the other version and wished the woman wasn't there :) and here it is, very nice one Avi!
|
|
|
|
|
Wolf Zorrito
{K:8532} 7/17/2008
|
Still room for many more pasts to come .........
|
|
|
|
|
fotogr@vi
{K:50665} 7/17/2008
|
Yes, I realized immediately as my friend Syamantak mentioned the same (in my language).. I was having a feeling something doesn't work.. and bingo !!.. I LOVE Usefilm beacuse of these positive critiques..
cheers my friend !
Avi
|
|
|
|
|
Jim Loy
{K:22878} 7/17/2008
|
Wonderful... have you ever seen the movie "Dead Poet's Society" ? There is a scene where the teacher makes the students look at images of long past students and whispers, "Carpe Diem..." while they take it all in... That one moment is worth watching the entire movie.
|
|
|
|
|
Moises Levy
{K:722} 7/17/2008
|
Interesting in B&W, Congrats....
|
|
|
|
|
Stan Hill
{K:10040} 7/17/2008
|
Are these your BIP or POD. It is all good at UF. thanks for all the imagination you share with us and the comments you share as well. Be well, Stan
|
|
|
|
|
Aline Nedelec
{K:1067} 7/17/2008
|
Once again, giving a short look at the recent pictures, your catch my eyes. Where does come from your smart and sharp eye ?
Just a low POV and a semi framing, and it makes all the difference.
I would like to know why you choosed noise, and if you added it on post-process. On my mind, it adds some mistery and softness to the picture, in harmony with this gallery of remembrance.
Sorry for my english.
|
|
|
|
|
txules .
{K:29399} 7/17/2008
|
very interesting, actually love the large empty room because adds a lot of tension; distorsion, noise and softness makes a strange picture which i love it;
excellent....txules
|
|
|
|
|
absynthius .
{K:16995} 7/17/2008
|
phenomenal minimalistic work Avi,
it feels like the canvas sinking, with 'all the faces in the mirror', never willing to stop dropping- and thus giving room to a shapeless formation eternal white- eternal wash away--- ghost indeed,
brilliant work Avi,
v.
|
|
|
|
|
Aniket Chakrabarty
{K:2469} 7/17/2008
|
This one is really good. Jio mama.
|
|
|
|
|
Gary Hill
{K:31539} 7/17/2008
|
The composition and the grain/noise appeal to me, Avi. It's another powerful image.
Regards, Gary
|
|
|
|
|
Anirjoy
{K:609} 7/17/2008
|
oosaa idea!! achha chobigulor deoal e setting ta je straight line e boshano sheta slightly daandike tilt ki?
|
|
|
|
|
soumya
{K:4324} 7/17/2008
|
na avi da eta ekdom bhalo laglo na. no story, more towards abstractness. the vignetting at the corners is not needed. aager dutoi better chhilo etar cheye. sorry.
|
|
|
|
|
fotogr@vi
{K:50665} 7/17/2008
|
jodio the top row of pictures is not in a st line, tobuo tui thik i bolechhish. ami 17mm e ektu wide niyechhilam, tate oi jinishta kheyal korini. anyway, I was more interested in the compo.
|
|
|
|
|
fotogr@vi
{K:50665} 7/17/2008
|
Ni I did not Jim. On your tip, I looked it up on imdb, liked what I read, and added it on my Netflix list. Thank you very much !
best, Avi
|
|
|
|
|
fotogr@vi
{K:50665} 7/17/2008
|
ha ha ha.. thanks Stan !! cheers, Avi
|
|
|
|
|
fotogr@vi
{K:50665} 7/17/2008
|
Thanks very much, Aline. Well, I usually try to think differently and avoid the cliche when I am composing a shot in my mind (or in front of me, with my eyes).. maybe that's what you see.
About the noise, I added it, to give it an old film-like effect, to go with the mood and story I am trying to tell here.
cheers,
Avi
|
|
|
|
|
fotogr@vi
{K:50665} 7/17/2008
|
Thank you !! :):)
cheers !!
|
|
|
|
|
Kausik Mukherjee
{K:-199} 7/17/2008
|
Very interesting shot. Like the space above.
|
|
|
|
|
Ania Blazejewska
{K:12583} 7/17/2008
|
great idea dear Avi, interesting composition and suitable title
best regards,
Ania
|
|
|
|
|
Yazeed Jalili
{K:30182} 7/17/2008
|
Really I like it so much .............
|
|
|
|
|
Manu
{K:13063} 7/17/2008
|
Excellent idea and very well spotted giving it space to breathe....
Manu
|
|
|
|
|
Joggie van Staden
{K:41275} 7/17/2008
|
Hi Avi, I like the atmosphere created by the open space on top, giving it a sense of timelesness. The contrast and grain further enhance the atmosphere. Very creative work!
Joggie
|
|
|
|
|
Francisco N-G
{K:26892} 7/17/2008
|
Very nice study dear Avi, the weight at the bottom of the layout gives a sense of stability and immutable balance; like deeply saturated wood, sinks to the bottom of the lake. The mood is old and has the spirit of relics to be discovered. Great shot my friend!!!!
Cheers!
F.
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Maity
{K:6451} 7/17/2008
|
Great idea and good comp.Beautiful use of the grain,b/w and the empty space.
|
|
|
|
|
Abhirup Chakrabarty
{K:393} 7/17/2008
|
past=vast ocean of memories left behind/void..sheta bojhanor jonne otota negative space rakha...and the pictures=ghosts.....khub shundor story telling....and the framed pictures give me a feel as if they are crawling towards the upper part to fill up that void...as a story telling picture this is brilliant...but IMHO, negative space-ta arektu(just a little bit) kom rakhle parte...just a personal opinion.. :)
|
|
|
|
|
Anne Knes
{K:47193} 7/17/2008
|
Nice work !!!!!
|
|
|
|
|
fotogr@vi
{K:50665} 7/18/2008
|
Thanks very much, my friend !! cheers, Avi
|
|
|
|
|
Keith Saint
{K:10929} 7/18/2008
|
Your framer must love you Avi
Well done nice collection and still plenty wall
|
|
|
|
|
fotogr@vi
{K:50665} 7/18/2008
|
Thanks Keith. This was taken at the MoMa :)
|
|
|
|
|
Shadi Porooshani
{K:9701} 7/20/2008
|
excellent composition dear AVI
7+
|
|
|
|
|
Mehul Chimthankar
{K:17399} 7/22/2008
|
Hi Avi,
This is excellent stuff
Mehul
|
|
|
|
|
Nick Karagiaouroglou
{K:91061} 7/23/2008
|
See that, see that!!! I have a similar one, Avi, but yours is much better. I think that except the general view of "rectangles in a rectangle) the grain-like look adds a good touch of "aged" appeal, which then goes hand in hand with the "ghosts of the past". Still I wonder how to make those ghosts even more noticeable.... Any clue of what could be done in addition? I ask because I think that there is much more potential in such images but I didn't find it until now. :-(
Cheers!
Nick
|
|
|
|
|
fotogr@vi
{K:50665} 7/23/2008
|
niether do I ! .. but my thinking was more to obscure the 'ghosts' .. I dunno.. :)
|
|
|
|
|
gianna piano
{K:13280} 7/23/2008
|
great feel...
g.
|
|
|
|
|
Nick Karagiaouroglou
{K:91061} 7/24/2008
|
Obscure the "ghosts"... but how? Good idea in the theoretical parts of it, and just because of thos you put me into deep doubts.. Obscure ghosts, he says.. But they *are* already ghosts, so how to obscure them?
Avi, you have a very nice and a very hard property for me! You state things that are good for a puzzling beyond all trusty boundaries, you know that? There he goes and simply says "obscure the ghosts"!! ;-)
Cheers!
Nick
|
|
|
|
|
fotogr@vi
{K:50665} 7/24/2008
|
:):):) .. I am prone to confuse people with my thoughts and words.. because, I am super confused myself !! :):)
cheers !!!! (no confusion over THAT !!)
Avi
|
|
|
|
|
Nick Karagiaouroglou
{K:91061} 7/25/2008
|
At least *some* few things remain clear! ;-)
Cheers!
Nick
|
|
|
|
|
Mohsen Bayramnejad
{K:21434} 7/27/2008
|
Outstanding...
|
|
|
|
|
Peter De Rycke
{K:39324} 7/27/2008
|
Nice work !
|
|
|
|
|
Hussam AL_ Khoder
{K:59859} 7/28/2008
|
nicee...
nicee...nicee...
nicee...nicee...nicee...
nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...
nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...
nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...nice e...
nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...nice e...nicee...
nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...nice e...nicee...nicee...
nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...nice e...nicee...
nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...nice e...
nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...
nicee...nicee...nicee...nicee...
nicee...nicee...nicee...
nicee...nicee...
nicee...
|
|
|
|
|
fotogr@vi
{K:50665} 7/28/2008
|
Dear Hussam,
I am happy to receive your enthusiastic comment, but it really does not help me towards improving my work. Please do not misunderstand me, but I would appreciate it a lot if you write a smaller and more meaningful critique.
best regards always, my friend.
Avi
|
|
|
|
|
violetta tarnowska
{K:23960} 8/6/2008
|
Bravo!
Good composition and frame.
I like here grain and tones.
Warm hugs:)
Viola
|
|
|
|
|
fotogr@vi
{K:50665} 8/6/2008
|
thanks Viola !!
hugs,
Avi
|
|
